I actually liked this brand of eyeliner. The tip is very soft and glides on without any tugging. I like the rubber tip on the end too. I like to smudge with it at certain parts of my eyelids. Good product.

I love this eyeliner I use it everyday and it looks great.

As usual Maybelline always comes up with perfection. Maybelline's Define-a-Line Eyeliner makes it easy to highlight upper and lower eye lashes with a perfect straight line. Also great for cat eye look or when you want a more dramatic look for evening. I have small eyes and it really makes them look brighter and larger. Great product. I highly recommend Maybelline's Define-a-Line Eyeliner to all my friends.

I really like this pencil. I bought it by accident one day as I was away in Hawaii. I needed something for my brows and since they didnt stock on eyebrow pencils, i decided to go try this eye liner as an alternative. It did an ok job for my brows but its amazing for upper lids!! i love it. I now wished to buy a darker colour but apparently its out of stock in canada (or i was told by a friend who went to rexall)!!! I hope this isnt true as i was preparing to buy the black one ! It last long and it stays put! it also glides on so silky smooth and i like how fast i can put my makeup on with this! It's awesome!

Stayed on for a while. Never smudged that much which you need for a cat eye!

I really wanted to like this product. Maybe I just got an old product but mine was super hard and chalky. It also kept breaking when I applied a tiny amount of pressure.

I really love this product. it works wonders.

I did not like this one at all. I wear it on both my top and bottom lids and it does not stay on. It runs down my face and I look terrible within an hour of putting it on. It is very oily. I would not buy again.

I love how Maybelline New York Define-A-line Eyeliner goes on and it last all day as well. I darken my eyes up with it later on in the day to make it a smokey look. Love this so much.

i love this eyeliner! i have bought it 3 times..will deff. bye for a 4th time :)