I brought this eyeliner a long time ago and it is still barely used to this day, the main reason is I don't wear makeup everyday because on the days that I do, I definitely go for this eyeliner and it has lasted a very long time, the consistency is good

First, I have to say that I never really liked gel eyeliner. This one made me change my mind. It's absolutely wonderfull. The color is intense and it last during the entire day without flaking off. Also, it's easy to apply and you don't have to put 3 coats to get a full coverage! I'll definetly buy the other colors!

This is hands down my favorite eyeliner. This eyeliner is so deep black and never flakes off. Its very easy to apply, and that says a lot (especially considering the fact that I have very bad sight). I love the formula, and it lasts a really long time too.

My sister received this product (and the brown colour) for free when they first came out forever ago, and since she doesn't use this product passed them on to me. Firstly, I've had these gel liners forever and they're STILL consistent. It doesn't dry up in the pot over time and has remained creamy. It still goes on like a dream. For the price, it's definitely worth it because a little goes a long way (for me). They also last years, so you definitely get the bang for your buck. As for the quality, I have oily eyelids and it tends to slip/smudge, so I would recommend using a lid primer to keep them in place. I'm not too crazy about the wands that come with the pot, but they aren't the worse things I've ever used. I use my own angle brush, but I would have no issues with using the brush it comes with. I would recommend this product to anyone who wants a good drugstore product that is reasonably priced and great quality.

I got this product a few months ago and I've hit pan! The texture is pleasing. It glides on the eye without being runny. The product lasts a long time and is quite good quality for the money you pay.
I'm not usually a fan of eyeliners in pots (I'm an adept of felt tip liners) but this one was precise enough and the colour pay off was far better than more high-end felt tips.
I would suggest you buy a separate eyeliner brush as the one they give you is pretty bad quality. You can work with it, but it's not worth the hassle.
To make this short, this product is opaque, easy to use and worth the price (around 9-10$ in Canada)

I like the idea of this, but I really didn't like the formula. I find gel liners a pain to apply and the staying power isn't the best either. I like Maybelline products because of the price and sometimes you can find a good quality product of out of the bunch. I use other products from this brand, but for some reason I can't get into the gel eyeliner.

I love this gel liner!! A little goes a long way, I've had it for months now and use it almost daily I've barely got into the pot!! I noticed it had dried up after a couple of weeks. I spreaywd mist fix plus by makeup forever in it and its like new, almost better then new! Soo smooth and creamy! It has amazing hold, last all day long without smudging! Perfect gel liner for professional use as well, I keep one in my kit! I do not use the brush it came with it, I didn't like it at all! Buy yourself a good little brush to get nice fine lines!!

This product is pricey and it looks like it's tiny and wouldn't last very long, but honestly the price is pretty much this products biggest downfall. You only need the smallest amount to cover a full eyelid and the brush, while handy if you don't own many cosmetic tools of you own can be a nice bonus addition, it doesn't apply as wel as one would hope. The fibers on mine split a tiny bit and I wasn't able to get a nice thin line.

First of all, throw away that brush it comes with... and buy yourself a real eyeliner brush to effectively use this product!
Ive been using this for years and i absolutely LOVE IT! it stays on for a solid 8 hours, I find it helpful when u use mascara on the lower lashes, it helps retain the product better (no panda smudge).
I use this product on my upper and lower water line only ( I use liquid for eyelids), and this is a very easy and creamy product, goes on easily.
highly recommend!

This is a very good gel eye liner from a drug store brand. It comes with a brush but I would recommend using an angled brush to really get precise lines around the curve of your eyes, and to create wings. Reasonably priced and long lasting. The colour is very rich and applies smooth.