Wow! This stuff is surprising! I received two as a gift ( one black and one navy) they both show really well! I was shocked.. Now for the down falls; it's a bit messy anyone not used to make up I do not recommend it. Also the pot and the brush separate? We have so many pen liners now this is just not practical or great for travel. It's good if you would like a make up for at home and you don't intend to carry around.

Love the intensity of the black color also it is really easy too apply on the lids and stay for a long moment. Better than any eye-liner i have EVER bought for myself

I really like this eyeliner! Love the intensity of the black. It's easy to apply and easy to remove with a makeup wipe. Very affordable and it lasts all day! Definitely recommend this to beginners :)

first gel liner I purchased and I don't regret it at all. I recommend this for beginners! It's fairly easy to use, you just need to get the hang of it. The eyeliner lasts a long time and the application is smooth. A lot of beauty bloggers recommended this gel eyeliner which is what lead me into buying it

Glides on easy. Perfect for the waterline as well as the lashline. Very dark black. Love how dark it is. It could be a little more waterproof. Overall nice find.

I like this eyeliner a lot it is long lasting will last you all day., and I find that it is easy to apply when you have the right brush of course looool

Inam using it from last one month, and it's best eyeliner I used so far. Eyes don't get watery at all, doesn't fade either. Using brush is very effective.

J'adore les eyeliner Parcontre je trouve plus difficile celui là.a cause qu'il faut le tramper dans le.noir et parfois on en met trop et sa tâche ! Ses un petit désavantage je croi

I love this eye liner,it gives a more defined look compared to the pencil,it doesn't smudge and is hassle free which I love.The price is amazing,I can always count on Maybelline products to be the best quality and this is my new go to eyeliner.I like being able to get a bold dramatic look when i'm going out on the town.I would definitely recommend this to everyone

I love this gel liner. It's equivalent to the Mac black trac. It's super black and it doesn't dry too quick. I usually set it with black eye shadow because my eyes are sensitive and get watery very easily so setting it with eyeshadow makes it last longer and keep it from bleeding.