This is the only liner that doesn't smudge that I have tried. I absolutely love it!!

This is a great gel eyeliner. It's very creamy and smooth and it comes with its own applicator brush which is easy to use. Just be careful with the product drying in the pot.

I was sceptical buying this product, but am so glad I did! It stays on with the same intensity from application, it doesn't smudge, and it doesn't copy. This is a must have in your make- up bag!

I love this eyeliner better than the MAC one. I think it's crazy pigmented and so creamy and easy to use. Definitely pick it up, for the drugstore price, it's basically heaven.

I just got this gel eye-liner two months ago for first time and i just LOVED it. I have only tried Mac gel liner before and I can say that Maybelline eye line is way better quality and less price than Mac one. unlike Mac eye-liner its very creamy and black.

Maybelline Eye Studio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner in Black .. i like gel eyeliner alot better then mechanical pencil eyeliner .fine gel stays on alot longer .

This is a very good quality gel eyeliner. it is easy to apply and looks amazing.

Loved the eyeliner, it did last all day-long for me, very little smudging, the only thing I wasn't crazy about was the brush, I had to use my own, because the one that comes with it is a little to thick for my liking (and to do the fine lines/retouching).

Definitely one of my top 5 eyeliners. This eyeliner has an amazing creamy consistency which easily glides onto the eyelid.

This gel eyeliner is awesome with the right brush. I usually use an e.l.f precision brush, because I don't want to ruin a higher end angled brush, and once you get the hang of it, it's great. It dries matte, unlike some of the other drugstore gel liners that dry shiny. It doesn't transfer to your upper lid, which is excellent for those of us with hooded eyes.