It gets the job done but can be a little hard to work with.

Loved the eyeliner, it did last all day-long for me, very little smudging, the only thing I wasn't crazy about was the brush, I had to use my own, because the one that comes with it is a little to thick for my liking (and to do the fine lines/retouching).

I love this liner in black. It is so pigmented and so easy to use. I tried to eggplant one, and it was the greatest. The product was too dry to even come on the brush. But by far, the black is amazing.

Definitely one of my top 5 eyeliners. This eyeliner has an amazing creamy consistency which easily glides onto the eyelid.

This gel eyeliner is awesome with the right brush. I usually use an e.l.f precision brush, because I don't want to ruin a higher end angled brush, and once you get the hang of it, it's great. It dries matte, unlike some of the other drugstore gel liners that dry shiny. It doesn't transfer to your upper lid, which is excellent for those of us with hooded eyes.

pricey but works great lasts long too!!!!! you get what you pay for right :)

I love the gel liner it is smooth easy to remove and long lasting. one thing i must say is that the brush is not the best brush around.. I really dislike the brush but aside from that the gel works perfectly.

I found this to be a good eyeliner, however, it's not 100% smudge proof as people with oily eyelids will have this smudge off pretty quick. I use this for a winged-line look and it's not bad. I only wished this stayed on longer than 30 mins.

A friend recommended this gel liner, which I bought about 1 month ago. Things that I appreciate is it's "easier to apply" "no sharpening" and "doesn't smudge" ,,, just to name a few. I will definitely continue to use this product and recommend it to my other friends.

Eyeliners are different for everybody. I prefer liquid over gel because you get more control. This liner looked good over my eye shadow. I also like being able to make a winged look with liquid liners. You can make the same look but you need an angled brush or something better. I found that this eyeliner smudge a bit. I think it just okay..