I use this when I need a gel liner that doesn't budge. For a fraction of the price of the MAC gel liner, this works perfectly. Absolutely love it.

I loved this eyeliner! Makes trying different looks easy! Very easy to apply and long wear !! Well worth the try!!

If Essence's gel eyeliner in Midnight in Paris (black) was no longer available I might have to reconsider the maybelline version..but as it is, Essence's lasts longer, has a truer black, doesn't smudge and is cheaper than the Maybelline one, so there's really no reason for me to re-puchase this.

This smudges like crazy on me and irritates my sensitive eyes.

Given that eye make up should be replaced every 6 months or so, I was looking for an alternative to my beloved MAC fluidline since it became costly to replace on a regular basis. After seeing many other users rave about this product, I decided to try it for myself. I'm glad I did, as this liner is quite pigmented and the staying power is great. And as a bonus, it comes with a decent brush. Overall, this is a great staple and dupe without breaking the bank.

Love this gel liner! I am a big fan of liquid liner, and was pleasantly surprised with how similar and easy to use this gel liner was. It stays put and doesn't smudge, which is so important.

This was a first gel liner I've ever tried and from what I've seen, this gel liner works just as great or even better than some high end gel liners. It is very creamy, glides on smoothly and long lasting ! I 've gon 8 hours with this gel liner and there were very minimal, unnoticeable smudging!

I love this stuff. I am a makeup artist so i use a lot of gel and liquid eye liners and this is the first department store brand version I have bought and i delivers everything it promises. Goes on smooth and easy and stays on all day and stays on just as dark as when you first applied it.

This is the best gel eyeliner I've tried. It is conveniently also waterproof, and I find that this gel liner is the best for building up a thicker line. May be difficult to use at first but it's really easy after a few more tries. The thin brush that comes with it allows you to easily create a sharp winged look.

Fantastic! It is easy to put on, doesn't feel clumpy, leaves beautiful lines and looks amazing. I originally bought it for tightlining ... now I'd be lost without it!

Bought this over two years ago and still have lots left and i wear make-up everyday...got it at wal-mart for $8 very cheap and lasts a long time i recommend this to everyone