Especially for the price, you can't beat this product. Stays on, even through some of the damp and humid weather that's been around the past weeks. I love teh pigment, rich and even to apply, only thing I"m not in love with is teh brush, I prefer a longer and slimmer brush for a more precise line and control when applying.

I love the liner, but think it is a little expensive for a drug store. This retails for about 10$ each. The packaging is nice and sleek black and glass so it doesn't look cheap. The consistency is very nice and makes sharp lines. It also doesnt have that annoying scent. With that being said, it tends to dry out and become dry and hard to spread since it is not as air tight at the MAC liner, but popping it in the microwave for a few seconds fixes that. It is great and very black and i recommend it as a very good liner.

My friend recommended me using this product after I was finished my other eyeliner. I bought this products months ago and I do like how it looks on my eye. The applicator made it easy for me to apply the eyeliner. The price is a bit pricey if you're on the budget, but it does stay on. The quality is worth of your money, and I really like the product, itself. Since I have oily skin, I have to reapply it, but it's not a problem.

Definitely my new eyeliner for the season!!!! I think I paid about 8 dollars for this, and I picked it up at Target. Nice, creamy gel eyeliner that goes on very smooth. Nice pigment, doesnt usually require double applications. I do recommend making sure you keep the lid on the product, or it will dry out and crack. THe brush that comes with the eyeliner works well and does give you a precise application, however I prefer the bent eyeliner brush by Sonia Kashuk.

Sexy! I love the precision I can get with the brush, the long handle makes it really easy to use, and it lasts for such a long time.

This is the best gel eyeliner i have ever tried and by far the most inexpensive!
It goes on extremely smooth and stays on as long as you want it to. I was nervous that it would be a bit tricky to get off but it was surprisingly easy with little to no scrubbing which is fantastic because my eyes are very sensitive to that. The black is a very deep color and it stays super dark without fading.
Definatly worth buying!

I think that this product is effective and good quality, but I find that it gets onto my crease. But I also found a way to stop it from causing that. But instead of talking about the cons, I will talk about the pros. This eyeliner has a great dark colour, like you can really tell that it's pure black. And the duration of this product is very long - I have had mine for the past year and every time that I wear it I get compliments.

Overall I believe that this product is worth the price and it comes to the expectations.

I find it smudges, and goes into my crease to easily. Its also a tad thick and maybe I was just putting too much on but I tried to get the tinest on the brush and found it applied like a layer of frosting.
I prefer the pen type eyeliners over the gel.

I really liked the soft glide of this eyeliner. Pencil liners tug my eye and I dislike sharpening them and the frustration of the breakage and sharp edges. This Maybelline Eye Studio Gel Eyeliner makes a very crisp line and I like the control of being able to make a thin or thick line. The eyeline lasted quite well and made my eyes look very dramatic. Very effective, hats of to Maybelline again, I love there products.

This product is decent, It doesn't give me the harsh line effect that I was looking for when I purchased the liner, its a little more smudged looking. It has pretty good staying power and does not feel super dry on your lid which I liked.
It is easy to apply but when I'm using the brush provided i cannot get a perfect winged look. Nonetheless, it does a good job at lining the upper and bottom lines and giving the smokey look.