This is by far the best eye liner. It is very precise and roughly stays more than 10 hours ( I normally remove it after 8-10 hours). It's the darkest black. It glides very smoothly and does not smudge at all. I have been using it almost everyday since last 3 months and it's still good. I already purchased the next one for backup but it's still running. So it's really cost effective. I totally recommend this to everyone specially to people who find the liquid liner messy like me

I have used liquid eyeliner on the tops of my lids for a few years now and this is one of my favorite liquid eyeliners that I've ever used. It's super easy to apply and helps to keep the lines straight. The tube also lasts a good while. I generally only apply once in the morning, but I will occasionally touch up if we go out in the evening. Otherwise, it goes on smoothly and I would recommend it!

I wasty happy with this. it seme to flake off in a few hours. it didn't last long had to reaply befor it started flaking . I well not be paying this again

This eyeliner goes on smoothly and dries fast. Make sure to shake real good before using to get just the right amount of liquid onto pen. I like how easy this eyeliner is to apply and that it isn't messy.

Ehhh, it's okay.. I've defiantly used better!! But I'd still buy it again. I know mixed emotions. I found the one I had was alittle more liquidity that I really liked, but it stays on once you get it to your perfect match.

The packaging and style of this liquid liner makes it so easy to apply. But i found that i had to go over a few times to get the right black shade i wanted. Although I got the liner in Black the first application showed more of a dark gray and when i reapplied it just clumped the product on my lids. Not my choice of liquid liner.

I only use maybelline brand eyeliner
The pencil for bottom and liquid on top
Absolutely love both !
Definitely my go to product I can't go without eyeliner

I was so excited when I saw this on the shelf of my local Walmart. Unfortunately, it was incredibly disappointing. It claims to have a good, steady flow. It did not. It usually takes four or five times going over to actually get any color. Just utilizing the tip, to get a small precise line, didn't deposit any product on my eye. Using the whole side length gave some product. And forget about trying to apply it over eye shadow. Would not recommend, will not be purchasing again.

Maybelline liquid eyeliner is another product I wear every time I apply makeup. It is a great value, easy to apply and is long lasting. It has never failed me, and is smudge proof. My daughter also uses this product as well we sometimes mix up who's is who's. I love this product and highly recommend it to any one.

This is the only liquid eyeline i will use! Has a fine precision tip which is perfect for the days i need An extra sexy cat eye! I use the blackest one because i like a lot of definition around my eyes!