Good for one use

I bought this after reading an article stating that this was better than stila's stay all day liner. I opened it and did a wing on each eye. I knew it would take me a few days to get the hang of this applicator because the tip is not freely movable but would seemingly give me thinner lines with less pressure. It lasted all day. The cap is not loose, however it does not give you the satisfactory click upon closing. The next time I attempted to use it, and any soft strokes left no pigment. I had to press like I've been using this liner for weeks. No worth it.

Not a fan

I was excited to try this because it had really good reviews on every site I looked. I was disappointed though. Took a few coats to get a pigmented line so it was hard to get a sharp dark wing. After just a few hours it had rubbed off on my upper eyelid and my attempt at a wing was just non existent anymore. I gave it another try the next day and the same thing happened. I'll stick with the Nyx Epic Ink liner, its around the same price and the best I've ever used.

Not worth the money

I purchased this product two weeks ago in even trying it for only a couple of times I was completely disappointed. It would stay wet for a longer period than what I'm used to and it would smudge all over my eye.

I wasty happy with this. it seme to flake off in a few hours. it didn't last long had to reaply befor it started flaking . I well not be paying this again

I was so excited when I saw this on the shelf of my local Walmart. Unfortunately, it was incredibly disappointing. It claims to have a good, steady flow. It did not. It usually takes four or five times going over to actually get any color. Just utilizing the tip, to get a small precise line, didn't deposit any product on my eye. Using the whole side length gave some product. And forget about trying to apply it over eye shadow. Would not recommend, will not be purchasing again.

This eyeliner looks like eyeshadow in just a short time. Even with eyelid primer it doesn't last. It goes on well, but does not hold a line at all.

I find it hard to apply and smudges off

just as good as any other eyeliner pen. wouldn't pay that much for it.