Unfortunately, the Voluptuous Lash Stiletto mascara was discontinued, so that sucks because it was my favourite.
This one is a close runner up, although the brush doesn't grab the lashes as well as the Voluptuous S-Shaped brush did.
Still gives good length, and the waterproof version holds all day!

I find this mascara gives my lashes good length. I find it light enough that after I curl my lashes it doesn't straighten them out again. It does not clump and I find it easy to wash off with just warm water.

If you want length, this is the mascara for you. I've repurchased this many times - either in the regular or waterproof version and I'm never disappointed. It is a definite favourite and I always go back to it if there is no new mascaras I want to try!

I have used this mascara for years, it goes on smooth mot clumpy, it make my lashes full and stand out.

This mascara adds the extra length I've been looking for. Love the look it leaves me with. Makes lashes look fuller and longer.

I like the brush, I use the wand in another mascara as I personally found this one dried out quiet quickly for me.

Maybeline New York Stiletto Mascara has its goods and bads.
Its great at lengthening your lashes and the black is nice and dark.
But I do not like the smell and I find it doesn't dry quickly, so I have managed to smudge it!

All in all its not terrible, but its not my first choice.

Love the effect that it gives my lashes. Always a go to staple in my makeup bag

So far my favourite mascara iv'e ever used! It gives me beautiful long lashes without the clumps! Love it!

this produt make my lashes felel and look longer it lasts all day too i am very satisfied with this product