this mascara left my lashes so clumpy and did the complete opposite of what is advertised, i am a fan of maybelline products but i know that i definitely would not buy this particular mascara again, just doesnt seem to work for me, i know of others who it has worked great on, just not a product for me.

I’m not a fan of Maybelline mascaras; they just don’t work on me. Surely I can’t pick the duff one every time? But I was wandering though my local Boots and saw the display for this new mascara… So I gave Maybelline another chance.


One coat of LASH STILLETTO is really all you need for beautifully separated, evenly coated, non-clumpy lashes. Because of the perfect separation your eyes look much more alert. It grabs, coats and pushes every lash out and up (even those little stragglers in the outer corners of the eye). I've not experienced flaking or smudging.
Plus, it holds my curl all day.

I prefer to use two coats; the tapering effect of the lashes is much more dramatic with two. Also; the colour is very vivid with more then one coat. Yes, it does have that weird honey scent that Colossal has, but I actually quite like the smell.
BTW: the ads don’t promise more volume, so I don't get why people complain about the lack of increase.

This is a great every-day mascara. I’m impressed by the fact that I get the results the ads promise. A first from Maybelline.


The packaging is cute & the price is right.

I've tried many mascaras, but this one is my fave under $10. It goes on nicely, with a more watery texture than other clumpier thicker mascaras. Has a very wet feel to it while brushing, which makes it easier to correct while applying. Love it!

(the one I have is the black packaging with a straight brush)

NO! NO! NO!

I would never purchase this mascara again. Although it does provide exceptional length, it clumps horribly. It also starts to flake off during the day, so it doesn't provide a long lasting mascara wear.

Definitely wouldn't recommend this product.

Clumps, Flakes, Ugh! My lashes all stuck together so it looked like i had about five spikes on each eye. What a waste of money. Smelled not-so-pretty too.

I like that this makes my lashes ultra black, but it flakes off pretty easily. I wouldn't say that this defines and lengthens the appearance of my lashes. It's just a general mascara like anything else.

It works on my lashes very well

Works for length but flakes and clumps easily

I have always had trouble getting my lashes to look long and full. My sister told me about this and now I use nothing else but this.

I hated this stuff. I found it to flake off really easily and really quickly. I would never buy it again.