This is a pretty good mascara to add length to your lashes. It is not super special though. There are a lot of mascaras that do the same

I like this mascara with a thickening mascara on top.
I find when I use this product alone I don't have enough volume.
It does give my lashes awesome length and it isn't clumpy either.

Rich colour, easy to apply, and it didn't go flaky or clumpy, as long as you don't use a very heavy hand to apply it. I always buy the deepest black I can find, and this one did not disappoint.

This mascara adds extra length to my lashes, does not clump and lasts all day. I have been using this for years and the waterproof is one of my holy grail drugstore mascaras. I will continue to repurchase.

If you want length, this is the mascara for you. I've repurchased this many times - either in the regular or waterproof version and I'm never disappointed. It is a definite favourite and I always go back to it if there is no new mascaras I want to try!

Maybeline New York Stiletto Mascara has its goods and bads.
Its great at lengthening your lashes and the black is nice and dark.
But I do not like the smell and I find it doesn't dry quickly, so I have managed to smudge it!

All in all its not terrible, but its not my first choice.

For the most part this mascara works well. It is a creamy texture and I did not experience a bunch of little filaments or dried pieces going all over my face. It does clump a bit in some spots but does make the lashes look thicker and longer. Overall for the price, a great product. Easy to clean off as well.

Awesome coverage. My sister could tell that I had mascara on my usual naked eyes right away. What really impressed me was the long lasting effectiveness of this product.

As far as drugstore mascara, it's fairly expensive but it is absolutely fantastic

Love this mascarra, makes my lashes full and long. Not dry or heavy feeling. Lasts all day and easy to remove at the end of the day. great price point too