It does lenghten lashes, however I usually find myself standing in front of the mirror applying mascara for five minutes. If you need to re-apply later in the day, it all has to come off otherwise it ends up completely clumpy. I like how much lenght was added to my eyelashes however there are tonnes of mascaras out there that do the same thing without the added time and clumping.

I recieved the Lash Stiletto in the mail from the product review club. My first impression of the product wasnt that great, as when i pulled out the wand, eager to try it, the wand broke inside the tube. Maybeline was nice enought to send me another tube. But even after trying the new mascara, i dont think i would change to it from the one i am using right now. I have really long eye lashes and they are pretty thick i guess. I like my lashes to be super black and the colour in the stiletto wasnt exactly what i wanted. I also found that the wand was a little akward to use. i just generally dont like small tiped wands becuase of my eyes. I still use it from time to time for a day to day wear but i wouldnt use it for going out at night.

I have to agree with some of the over reviewers when I say that this mascara lacks volume. The length I definitely got; it stretched out my eye lashes a far bit. But as a result, it gave me those long, dreaded "spider lashes".

The packaging is definitely really cute and small (takes up far less space than my Covergirl LashBlast!) But the product inside the bottle is really what counts. This one didn't do it for me.

I was skeptical about this product. When applied correctly, brushing the tops and bottoms of the eyelashes, it does give the appearance of long, full and shiny eyelashes. You can apply as many coats as desirable and it continues to thicken, lengthen and shine your lashes with each application. It's a bit harder to remove than normal mascara.

It worked like any other mascara really nothing too exciting.
It says its a black deep shine there was no shine what so ever and almost a soft black not an extreme high shine as promised. I didt notice making my lashes longer. I wont be buying this product again,

What it is: lengthening mascara. Claims to be "the sexiest thing" your lashes will ever wear, or something like that.

Where to get it: drugstores and everywhere else Maybelline products are sold.

How much: $7-$8

What I like about it: this product was good at separating and keeping my lashes separate. Also, it didn't clump and didn't flake.

What could be improved: this definitely was not the sexiest thing my lashes could ever wear. It lengthened my lashes just a touch, but nothing impressive. I haven't tried it over curled lashes so I can't really say if it holds a curl well or not.

Overall: if you're nearest drugstore or retailer is having a buy one/get one free type of offer on maybelline cosmetics, then this product might be worth a try. But if you have to shell out almost 10 bucks for broken promises, then definitely just save your money, I'd suggest buying TWO of maybelline's 'Great Lash' mascaras instead.

I purchased one of these mascaras the day they came in at work, because it was our item of the month.
Normally, I'm not a huge fan of Maybelline, but loved their last mascara and thought id try this one.

When I first opened the tube, I was delighted by the scent. It smells almost like a freshly watered garden, and the brush makes it very easy to apply. I didnt find it much different from the other Maybelline formulas though, apart from the cute packaging and nice scent.

Overall, this is a nice, budget friendly mascara to use for incredibly long lashes. It did well at seperating and lengthening, but I wouldnt reccomend this to a lady looking for more volume. So far, this has been a popular item with the ladies at work and It doesnt smudge easily, but it could be longer wearing .


I think colossal lash is still their best mascara. :)

This is a great product for people with lots of lashes who want stand out length. Definitely great at adding length but not good for my sparse lashes. I had to apply many coats & still only gained length. Will recommend for friends but not for self.

I was to receive this mascara from the product review club, but our postal service hates me, and lost the package, but no worries, I have the review!

So I thought the packaging was nice, but maybe they put a little too much into the packaging and the branding of stiletto and making the mascara look like a peg of a stiletto high heel. Either way this doesn't affect the product itself.

The smell was kind of weird, but not weird enough that I wouldn't purchase it again. Although it is the most smelly of all my mascaras...(and I buy new ones ALL the time).

The best thing about this mascara is that it actually did what it said it will, which is to LENGHTHEN your lashes. So I was very happy with the lenght, but I prefer a thicker, more volume look. SO based off that, I will continue to wear this mascara on lazy days and when I just need a little pick me up, rather than on the nights were Im out on the town with my girls.

Overall, not bad, good lenthening, weird smell, but will work fine for a natural, regular day look. :)

This mascara made my lashes a little bit longer but didn't do anything in terms of volume. Since that isn't the selling point of the mascara I think it did what it was supposed to but not what I'm really looking for in a mascara. I'll stick to my diorshow thanks.