I LOVE this eyeliner! It goes on so smoothly with absolutely no pulling, and once it sets it stays put all day. Great pigmentation! I keep comparing other liners to this one.

So pigmented and so smooth to glide on! The only downfall is that it wears down fast and the tip becomes blunt easily making it hard to control the thickness of the line. Other than that, best creme pencil ever!

This eyeliner is made of an oil-free cream formula with a high concentration of pigment. It goes on very smoothly and is easy to blend, and the color is quite opaque and bold. Maybelline claims that it is smudge proof and waterproof for up to 16 hours, but I'm not sure I agree with them on that after using the product. It is not entirely waterproof, but it does hold up pretty decently against oily skin or moisture in the air. I find that it does tend to "bleed" a little bit after a couple hours of wearing it. I'm also not really a fan of the eyeliner pencil design. You have to twist the bottom of the pencil to get the product to come through the tip, and at first the product is shaped into a point, but after a couple uses it is basically flat and kind of hard to do details with. You CAN try to pinch the product back into a point, but its a messy process and the product tends to break off when you do this. Still, not bad for a cream liner. Tip: to keep your liner from smudging or bleeding, use a thin liner brush to apply a couple strokes of eyeshadow (in the same color as the eyeliner) over your line and it will help keep it in place much longer. Translucent powder may work for this as well.

I tried "Midnight Master" because it was the blackest and I usually line my upper lids with a perfect black. This gel-cream pencil gives a smooth solid inky black line.

It's soft, blends well and last 4-6 hours. You'll have to reapply before going out. But, it's a great deal for a drugstore find.