a decent mascara

I always purchase mascara in waterproof as I have very sensitive eyes that water easily. I really like the brush on this tube of mascara as it grabs all your lashes. You will need to apply more than coat if you want to see long, thick lashes. If you apply three coats, you will definitely achieve a "false eyelash effect" Although this mascara is waterproof, it will come off easily with eye makeup remover formulated for waterproof cosmetics. The only critique I have of this mascara, is that when the tube gets old, the formula gets a bit clumpy.

Not worth it

I had high hopes for this mascara because I am a fan of the original Colossal, but was really disappointed. The bristles are quite sparse, and it takes several coats to cover lashes evenly. The formula is very wet and clumpy, and the brush makes it transfer easily to the eyelid when applying. In my opinion, it is not worth the extra money compared to the classic Colossal version. I do not recommend and will not be buying it again.

Love it!

This is my new favourite mascara, makes it look like it have extensions when I don't. Only thing I don't like is it can be really clumpy when it com a out of the tube so you have to be careful. Other than that I love it!

My new go to mascara! Wouldnt change it for anything else

Amazing value. Doesnt run or clump up. Makes your lashes look as long and thick as if you were using a 4d mascara. Absolutely love this and would not change it now that ive found it

Torn

I'm absolutely crazy about this brush and this formula... But it doesn't live up to its waterproof claims. I find mascara stamped under my eyes constantly, I have to use a second waterproof mascara to ensure I don't have raccoon eyes by the time lunch rolls around! I would buy this again but not in waterproof.

This mascara is by far the worst I have EVER tried, and believe me I have tried TONS! This stuff is junk! I don't understand the formula, it's supposed to be waterproof, ok, the texture feel like thick goopy honey on my eyes, I wasn't able to layer to get length, or to thicken. I am very disappointed in everything about this crap mascara, I believe I was duped into spending around $10ish on this, which is about $9.50 too much in my opinion! Honestly I'm not trying to be so harsh but it took me almost 45 minutes and a whole bottle of my micellar water to get this gunk off my eyes, which btw, has proven to get anything off in the past