This is my go to eyeliner

This is the only eyeliner that I have found that lasts all day without smudging underneath my eyes. Even other brands that say they are waterproof end up smudging by the end of the day. I am not dexterious enough to use a liquid liner. This pencil goes on easily, stays on, and comes off easily enough with makeup remover. It also does not require sharpening.

Best drug store eyeliner

For the price and every day use, it's actually not a bad product! It stays on for the most part of the day and is super easy to glide on. It's also self sharpening!

This eyeliner is a twistable top that gets rid of the pain of having to sharpen your eye liner pencil - just twist!
The Onyx Black colour is jet black, and looks great when applied - a nice smooth, dark finish.
This is also water-proof.