This is a great everyday eyeliner. I wouldn't say it's amazing or anything spectacular, but it does the job well. It's smooth and not too hard, and stays put both on the skin and in the waterline. It's great because it's a twist up and doesn't require sharpening. It comes in different colors and overall is a good product. You can find this pencil/crayon in the drugstore for less than $5. Definitely worth a shot. Good overall everyday and multipurpose liner.

This is my favorite eyeliner for smudging on the upper lashline and also great for the waterline. This is a twist-up, crayon style eyeliner -- very long wearing and creamy. This is a pretty smudgy, soft eyeliner, not so great for the lower lashline, but it's great for smudging on the upper lashline -- it diffuses nicely for a very soft and pretty effect. One of the best things about this eyeliner is the price, less than $4 USD at Target. Totally recommend it.