This is my favorite eyeliner for smudging on the upper lashline and also great for the waterline. This is a twist-up, crayon style eyeliner -- very long wearing and creamy. This is a pretty smudgy, soft eyeliner, not so great for the lower lashline, but it's great for smudging on the upper lashline -- it diffuses nicely for a very soft and pretty effect. One of the best things about this eyeliner is the price, less than $4 USD at Target. Totally recommend it.