Milani makes some really good, really inexpensive beauty products. I've used their eye shadows quite happily for a few years, they are super pigmented and easy to apply so I decided to take a chance on their pot eyeliner in Black Gold Foil - I'm glad I did. While there is a bit of smudging if you're not careful in application, it comes with a decent liner brush and goes on smoothly. I don't see much of the foil effect in the black - but I loved it so much I went out and bought the Purple Foil and the Brown Foil too! The Brown Foil definitely has a bit more shimmer, and the purple as well, tho I find the colour not as pigmented. Still, you can't beat the price, and the quality is quite good.