For its price, this makeup remover works relatively well getting non-waterproof makeup off. But I tend to wear waterproof eyeliner and mascara and it always takes some scrubbing to get it off and even then there's usually still some stubborn eyeliner left around the lashline.

I think this is the best remover available for the price. It works best if you don't wear waterproof eye makeup or heavy mascara. In that case, you might have to go over each lid thoroughly, twice. It works for me because my cleanser takes off any leftovers. I'll buy this again when I run out, unless I decide to splurge and pick up the Lancome Bi-Facil. That's the best remover in any price range.

The other day I commented on another Chick Advisor's review for Clinique's Take the Day Off Make-up Remover. In this review, the Sweet Chick wrote she would rather spend $6 on Neutrogena's Dual-Phase Eye Make-up Remover which was similar in action, rather than spend the $20 for Take the Day Off.

Now I am a HUGE fan of Take the Day Off but had not tried the Neutrogena Dual-Phase Eye Make-up Remover.

All I can say is wow! While Neutrogena's product seems to dry faster making your eye-lashes not feel as conditioned as the Clinique product, it is very effective! Not only is it packaged similarly (in a clear purple bottle) you are saving about $14, and a little of this product goes a long way.

Now, I am a loyal follower of Clinique and it is not a splurge for me to spend the $20 for my fabulous eye-make up remover, but for ladies on a budget who still want quality and consistency of a good eye make up remover this stuff works great!

My only complaint is that there is no safety seal on this product when you buy it in the store. I kinda like the fact the Clinique product at least comes in a sealed box (tamper resistant) but other than that, a great find and kudos to the Sweet Chick for the original suggestion!

For the price, this product can not be beat. I used to live for Lancome, but this leaves less of a greasy residue and gets the job done.

Someone call the Product Police! This "oil-free" eye makeup remover has two problems: first, it doesn't take off my makeup unless I scrub (and even then I need to do it 2 or 3 times before it's all off, and use a Q-tip to get the rest), and second, it leaves an oily residue behind that I always end up washing off anyway. And I don't use water-proof mascara... my facial cleanser does as good a job or better. Not worth it, but I must say I have yet to find a good eye makeup remover that costs $10 or less. Suggestions?