Not for my.

I really love it the products from neutrogena. I have so many products from this brand, but this remove eye make up doesn't work so well for my. First make my skin around the eyes get some pimples in the next day. And my eyes get very red. I don't know why. But my sister and my mom use for years and for them no have nothing better, they don't even want trie another product because this really work for them. My advice is trie! If you never trie you never know!

Doesn't burn or make face all red. Certainly not oil free its so greasy and you can see the oil in the bottle. Doesn't effectively take makeup off. I would rather use garnier micellar water .

Neutrogena products were always the best products out there but I have found over the years the more compition that's out there the worse there product gets! This product here Ive never had a eye make remover leave my skin so greasy Ive got to the point where I'm willing to spend a little more for skin products (Vichy) to do exactly what there suppose to!

This product did remove any and all eye makeup, but stung like the high heavens in the process. No jokes this product burned my eyes it hurt so bad. Wouldn't recommend it to my worst enemy

These looked so fluffy and soft and effective in the commercial, so I had to try them. I was a little shocked by the price, especially for the amount of product you got. They were dry and did nothing to remove my eye makeup, other than pull out some lashes. Disgusted, I ended up using them for my face makeup, which they could barely handle either. Serious let down, Neutrogena!

Someone call the Product Police! This "oil-free" eye makeup remover has two problems: first, it doesn't take off my makeup unless I scrub (and even then I need to do it 2 or 3 times before it's all off, and use a Q-tip to get the rest), and second, it leaves an oily residue behind that I always end up washing off anyway. And I don't use water-proof mascara... my facial cleanser does as good a job or better. Not worth it, but I must say I have yet to find a good eye makeup remover that costs $10 or less. Suggestions?