Never again buying this!

I normally really enjoy NYC products, they're inexpensive and effective. The eyeliner though is not worth the buy. It takes a long time to dry, it stains and makes a big mess. Since it takes a while to dry, most times it would stain the upper eyelids and ruin all the eye shadow I've already taken the time to do. There's plenty of eyeliners at that price point that do a way better job and that is less effort!