As everyone here, the product is amazing! The problem is if you apply too much its SO HARD to get rid of the excess product without some of the eyeliner going into your eye. (Welp, there goes all your makeup).But, 5/5 recommend - make sure to get the pure black not the pearl black for a matte finish!

Cheers xox

I was sick of paying upwards of $30 for liquid eyeliner. I bought this on impulse at my local drug store and holy wow was I ever impressed. I love the long brush and the fact that it dries matte. It is super easy to use and a $4.99 bottle lasts forEVER. I can't believe how much I was overpaying for something this simple.

love this liquid eyeliner. price is perfect and lasts a long time and the wand is easy to use.

This is the first eyeliner i've ever tried and it works even if my hand shakes. The price is great and on my oily lids it lasts for ages.

This is my holy grail. I love this product! It is super long lasting AND smudge proof! I regularly have worn it to bed (I know, not the best thing) and have woken up to it still being perfect. The application wand is great too! It isn't too flimsy and offer a great amount of control for a dramatic cat eye or a simple line across the lash.

This eyeliner is very good and very black
my only complaint and thing that holds me back from using this product more is the applicator/wand its too straight and long and hard to use

I usually use ELF liquid liner pen but because the store didn't have any when I went, I chose to buy this...it is terrible. Comes out grey and produces a faint line that is barely noticeable...if I could get my money back I would :(

I love this product and how long the bottle lasts me. It is such an affordable product which still packs a punch for its inexpensive cost. I love how the black almost has a metallic sheen to it as well. I would recommend this product to anyone who loves to save money. It lasts you forever.

I've been using this eyeliner for years because it's absolutely amazing!! The price can't be beat and it works really well. It has a really thin brush so you can make your line can be as thick or thin as you want, the thinness also makes it easy to apply. I've tried lots of other liquid eyeliners over the years and I always go back to NYC's!

This is one of my favorite eye liners. I love how it doesn't smudge and lasts a long time. I wish it could last longer but what can you do lol. The only thing I don't like is how fast the tube runs out. I wear eye liner every day and apply it once. I am currently looking for a new eyeliner but this one is def one of my favorites.