Im in love

I have used more then one eyeliner , and this one by far is the best , i usually use it when going out after i remove all my make up i still have the eyeliner on my eyes .
This is a must have if you have to put make up for all day

Never use this again

This i find is harsh on the eyes while applying it i rather no eyeliner then deal with pain putting it on. I would not use this product again. I would tell everybody not to buy unless you can handle pain putting it on

I have read some bad reviews on this but I think it's an amazing product considering I bought it for only a dollar at SDM. It is creamy and applies very easily you don't have to keep going back and forth with it. I use this to tight line and it stays in place for a good 3-4 hours. It does smudge but honestly any thing I put in my water line smudges. I don't mind reapplying

This product I found to be *okay*. It's nothing special and doesn't work amazing, but in a pinch you can make anything work. I wouldn't add this product to my daily regiment, but if it's all I had I would use it.

Very hard to work with and doesn't last all day, and it smudges.

The entire pencil is not an actual pencil, it's just the tip that's actually the liner, so I guess you really aren't getting that much product. It feels very dry when you try putting it on instead of smooth and creamy. You don't get that much pigment of off it. However, it does seem to work pretty well for waterline
(I got it in 932 dark brown)

Didn't smudge and was a great price.

okay so i have a review about NYC black nail polish and i didnt rate it much... but my friend during that time said that not all NYC products suck and told me that their waterproof eyeliner was amazing! i bought it reluctently but it was worth it! this is really worth it!! like seriously. it works well!, i use it alot! i just recently finished it up and am deffo gunna buy another one! if you would like more review on this product check this out: http://www.totalbeauty.com/reviews/product/6163081/nyc-new-york-color-waterproof-eyeliner-pencil :)