This is my first nyx lipstick. I am very pleased with this lipstick. I received it in my February 2017 glam bag. I am very surprised at how creamy it is. The name matches the product well as it really feels smooth like butter. I have dry skin and my lips are the worst. This lipstick really does help as it doesnt dry them out like previous lipsticks I have had in the past. The pigmentation is amazing, but the best part of this lipstick is the pigmentation. This lipstick really does last a long time. I still have the stain on my hand from swatching it and it has been hours. It comes of well with makeup remover, but does need a little push and scrub. I am excited and curious to try other shades.