It's cute, but no

I had the Mint Julep NYX Mascara. The color was vibrant and it looked pretty and all, but it just coated my lashes. The product is very liquidy and I received no volume, no added length, nothing really, but color. This mascara is also a pain to remove. So many of my lashes fell out! Not only did the mascara not wash off in the shower, but I had to use a makeup wipe for about 30 minutes to remove the color. My lashes felt dry and weak.

I love these two fun color mascaras. The purple one is "Forget Me Not Lavender" and the green one is Mint Julep.
They cost $10 each which I don't mind paying. I'm not great with mascara but I love them because when I wear some color I receive compliments. I have tiny eye lashes. The colors are packed full of pigments. The bush seems to attach like half the tube on it so you must wipe a lot off on the edge. I don't mind that. I have hooded eyes and I find when I use these I don't even need eyeliner. Less is better. How cool is that for someone like myself why has only been wearing makeup for a year and is a slow learner. Still having fun learning. I like these colors so much I feel happy when wearing them. That is after all who I'm trying to please...ME
Some people say its nearly impossible to remove. I guess even that doesn't bother me. I use a magic makeup cloth and most of it does come off.

I'll admit I was excited to find a coloured mascara. i remember having a bright blue and a neon yellow in the 80's. The mascara itself is decent, but you can't see the colour except up close in the magnified mirror, or at least that was the case for the purple colour. Perhaps the blue might work better.