This had great color pay off and doesn't dry out my lips! The price really can't be beat ether.

Smells great, great pigmentation, lots of colours. I love them! theyre a bit sticky but I find all glosses to be sticky. Layered over a nice lipstick and youre good to go!

I love the Butter Lip Gloss. It smells so yummy and it is the perfect gloss. I love wearing this over my lipstick. This is very reasonably priced.

Pros

Buttery
Creamy
Effective
Nourishing
Soothing
True Shade To Name

Cons

Not Long-Lasting
Sometimes too sticky

I don't wear a ton of straight up lip gloss anymore, but like to have at least one around. These are very popular my area apparently - we just got a small NYX display at Target and almost all of the lip products are sold out, especially the Butter Glosses! I found one in Vanilla Cream Pie, a light nude pink. I wish I could have gotten one of the more red or berry toned ones, but the Vanilla is really nice and layers well over some of my other lip products.
I find that most lip glosses aren't sticky at first, but they eventually become that way. I haven't had that problem yet with the Butter Gloss, and I find that it wears away evenly and nicely.
The applicator is a nice little doe foot, and the size of the lip gloss tube is small enough to fit in most purses or pockets without being an issue!
The scent isn't overpowering, just the usual faint vanilla type fragrance, and there doesn't seem to really be a flavour which is great.
I would definitely buy this again, especially if I can find some of the darker shades in my area.

I like this lip gloss. It smells and tastes good. it applies well but then I find it to be a bit separated once on the lips. It does give a nice colour payoff. It also stays on your lips for a long time.

I love NYX products because they are inexpensive and are better quality than many more expensive "low end" brands. If you're looking for a gloss with great colour and don't mind reapplying often, this is perfect!

Great product for the price. Not sticky, more like silky. Good color options. Wish it lasted just a tad longer.

I love most of NYX's products, and I really wanted to love this one, but it's just a miss with me. The color goes on splotchy and uneven (what little color there is) and the formula is too slick, thin, and watery. The smell is nice and I love that the formula is paraben-free, but it could use a little reworking.

This stuff is awesome, I only use lipgloss, I have tons of them, but I always reach for this one. It smells nice, my hair doesn't stick to it and it doesn't cost a lot!