I have only tried the color milk (and am on my third one right now). I find this better as a base than on its own, it starts to smudge away when worn on its own but when used as a base it lasts all day. I usually use this an eyeliner and then set it with a white eyeshadow on my lower lash line, and it holds up all day. This is also really good to use to cover up a mistake with winged liner too! I this lasts me about a month per stick but I use it as an eyeshadow base and a liner every day. I would recommend this to anyone because it has so many uses and is a great price.

I just bought this since the NYX store is now open and not crazy busy, and I just have to say that I love this product! I use my usual primer and then the pencil. I smudge the white over my eyelid and then put on my eyeshadow. The white makes the eyeshadow just pop! It also helps it stay on even longer. Very much love this and a must buy!

These are amazing. Firstly, theyr perfect as eyeliners or as eyeshadows, they double as both. They are also amazing as a base for your eyeshadow. I love these products as their very affordable.

I use this as an eyeshadow base to cancel out any redness/veining/discolouration on my lids.

Works like a dream!

It also does a great job and making any shadow you apply look brighter because it is sitting on a lightened "canvas".

Love it!

Whenever I do a makeup look with bright eyeshadow, I love using the NYX Jumbo Pencil in Milk to really make the colours pop! I apply it to my lids as a base, straight from the pencil, and blend it out a little with the warmth of my finger. Any colour I add over it is very vibrant! You can't go wrong for the price, give it a try!

My review of NYX Jumbo Pencil in Milk;
This creamy, blendable pencil is a matte white. It is perfect for brightening the inner corners of the eyes, as well as a base to make eye shadows pop. I love using this with the Urban Decay Electric palette to really make everything bright!

Amazing is all I can say. Goes on effortlessly and does not crease. Very smooth and creamy and blends like a dream. The pigmentation is also great. I bought one shade but will for sure get more.

I love this product , they make a beautiful color that lasts a long time. I recommend it to all the women who want to go fast in the morning. I had heard great reviews about it and it was really inexpensive.

This is the only one I will use. I have tried so many of them and none of them seem to works as well as this one. I use the white on my eyelids and I get lots of compliments on it. At Christmas I bought the set of all the colors to try and I have to say they are all great.

I bought milk to use for waterline and inner corners, it is great consistancy, size, product however I just dont like the look of using the product, Not NYXs fault, would repurchase in black.