As much as I love NYX products, they fall short on eyebrow products. If I'm being honest I only bought this eyebrow pencil because mine ran out and the store was out of stock.
It doesn't glide as nicely and tends to tug at eyebrow hairs to begin with; the colour was more orangey than blonde and didn't match my brows at all. It would be more suited for a natural redhead.
As for the outside, I don't really like how you cannot tell the colour on the outside and it seems a bit cheap and like it's barely staying together.
Unfortunately NYX has let me down with this product.