Would definitely buy this again!

I love this liquid eyeliner for everyday use. The pen itself is (as the name implies) super skinny! I am able to make really thin, precise wings, or can make bolder wings when I feel like it! And it’s soo easy to use (I’m no eyeliner guru). Great value as well (I bought this at the drugstore for $12 cad). Highly recommend!

So disappointing

The tip dries out and clogs up after one use. Didn't last even with a setting spray it was like a kohl eye liner pencil by sliding and smudging without touching and most definitely is not waterproof.

Not enough pigment

This one is not for me. It doesn't stay on and definitely not pigmented enough. Though, the felted tip makes application very easy. I won't be purchasing it again.

Worst Eyeliner ever

I purchased this eyeliner after hearing good reviews about NYX and looking for a good drugstore eyeliner (similar to the Physician's Formula's). Yes, the thin felt tip is nice and easy to use. However, there is almost no intensity to the colour, and you have to go over several time to get an even black-ish line. The worst part is the wear time. Within minutes it creases, smudges and starts to transfer everywhere. Forbid you touch your eye even a little, the liner will straight up jump from your eyelid to your hand or anywhere on your face.
I tried several cheaper drugstore liners that were a lot better ... And none that were worst. Pass.

I bought this because I LOVEEE NYX products. I wanted a matte black liquid eyeliner and this was the only one of they had. I tried to on my hand and worked perfectly (DON'T BE FOOLED!!!). However, getting it to work on your eyes is a different story. You have to apply soooo much pressure, you have to hold it at a certain angle or the product won't come out at all (gravity). It doesn't come out smoothly at all and you have to do it in tiny little sections,you really can't do one continuous line with this. This takes me easily 15-20 minutes to get both eyes done nicely whereas the regular liquid liner takes me about 5-10 min to get both eyes done beautifully. I've since gone back to my old stand-by of the 'NYX collection noir liquid black liner'.

I love this product. It is the most amazing eyeliner I ever owned. It is easy on the eyes, easy to control and the skinny tip helps to perfect the winged effect. I buy this religiously and the price is amazing for the quality of the product. I am a NYX fan. Being from a small town, I have a limited selection of drug store brand makeup and that is it; I am very glad that our drug store started selling this brand!

I could not be more disappointed with this product. I have to apply a lot of pressure to get my lines dark, it smudges very easily. I can buy better liquid eyeliner for half the price.

I had high hopes for this eyeliner, but I was really let down. It's a pen style, so you just remove the cap and apply the eyeliner. I purchased the color 01 Carbon Black, but it didn't live up to its name. The liner wasn't very opaque or black at all, and I constantly had to shake the liner to get product out. The tip is very thin but I find that the liner either barely comes out, or it runs all over. Other people seem to have had great luck with this eyeliner pen. I wish I liked it but it just didn't work for me. Disappointed.