So disappointing

The tip dries out and clogs up after one use. Didn't last even with a setting spray it was like a kohl eye liner pencil by sliding and smudging without touching and most definitely is not waterproof.

Not enough pigment

This one is not for me. It doesn't stay on and definitely not pigmented enough. Though, the felted tip makes application very easy. I won't be purchasing it again.

Worst Eyeliner ever

I purchased this eyeliner after hearing good reviews about NYX and looking for a good drugstore eyeliner (similar to the Physician's Formula's). Yes, the thin felt tip is nice and easy to use. However, there is almost no intensity to the colour, and you have to go over several time to get an even black-ish line. The worst part is the wear time. Within minutes it creases, smudges and starts to transfer everywhere. Forbid you touch your eye even a little, the liner will straight up jump from your eyelid to your hand or anywhere on your face.
I tried several cheaper drugstore liners that were a lot better ... And none that were worst. Pass.