I was completely disappointed in this product. I did love the pigmentation and how they went on. However, they broke after a couple of uses. One broke from being in my purse. It was a waste of money.

tried these out once and never again! Totally agree with them being crumbly! I expected better from this brand, since I have used their other products before. It's a shame because the colours are nice, but the eyeliner kept falling off the base, even when I wasn't using much pressure. I had to try to smush it back in the pencil, just so it wouldn't totally go to waste. It also goes on too thick....especially the closer u get to the bottom

I do like these! They glide on really smoothly and have great pigmentation. I don't really like the design though, 2 of mine fell out on the fist day! Otherwise, they are good.

I purchased this in the blue eyes trio. I find it doesn't glide on my eyes well and is very crumbly. If not for the rebate, I would have given this "It's a rip off" for the price portion.

What I Love:
- Beautiful shades and pigment (as shown in the pictures, just one stroke and you get tons of colour!)

- Glides on easily. The eyeliners are super smooth and easy to apply.

- Long lasting colour! This liner lasts all day long, however, it does smudge quite a bit, so be sure to dab some eye-shadow over it to avoid raccoon eyes!


What I dislike:
- Horrible design. The brown one (as you can see from the pictures) already broke from just 2 uses. It could’ve just been me being too forceful on the pencil itself when I was applying the product, but if it broke this early on then I’m afraid of breaking the other two also. The lid is also terrible because I’ve already accidentally scraped off the tip of my black one with the rims of the lid. You can’t even sharpen this eyeliner because of the strange triangular design, unless you have a large sized sharpener.

- Smudges easily.


All-in-all:
Compared to many other drugstore brands, this eyeliner is not a winner. The design itself outweighs the Pros because there are plenty of other eyeliners out there which are cheaper and designed better, and provides the same amount of pigment and results. I would not recommend this eyeliner if you have other choices (such as Rimmel’s Kajal Eyeliner – which is one of my favorites!).