tried these out once and never again! Totally agree with them being crumbly! I expected better from this brand, since I have used their other products before. It's a shame because the colours are nice, but the eyeliner kept falling off the base, even when I wasn't using much pressure. I had to try to smush it back in the pencil, just so it wouldn't totally go to waste. It also goes on too thick....especially the closer u get to the bottom

I purchased this in the blue eyes trio. I find it doesn't glide on my eyes well and is very crumbly. If not for the rebate, I would have given this "It's a rip off" for the price portion.