Been rocking the cat eye daily for 5+ years now. I've tried A LOT of different eyeliners: drugstore, higher end, Asian, pencil, gel, liquid, pen. I find that I keep coming back to this one.

Why I love it:

Colour intensity - super black. Only needs one swipe to get amazing colour payoff.

Wear - Lasts all day. Lasts all night. Lasts into the next day when you're out late dancing in a sweaty club and are too tired to remember to take it off when you get home. Waterproof, sweatproof, doesn't smudge.

Usability - Pen tip is nice and sharp so that my wings are always perfectly on point. Allows me to go super close to the lash line. Pens are also just great because they're so portable.

Price - Though it's not the cheapest drugstore eyeliner, I think that it's great value. Quite comparable to Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner or Kat Von D Tattoo Liner except way cheaper. Only North American drugstore liner that can even compare to the Asian ones which is great because it's much easier for me to find in Canada. A lot of pens dry out way too quickly for me, but this baby gives me razor sharp wings for months.

It boasts lash boosting properties but take this with a grain of salt. I didn't buy it for this reason and personally cannot say that I've noticed a change. Killing it in the eyeliner game but a total dud if you're looking to boost your lashes.

This is my favorite type of eyeliner. It comes in the darkest black. I didn't notice it making a difference on my eyelashes. It is so easy to put on so smooth and waterproof.

Best drug store eyeliner. Very affordable(grab it when it is on sale) and it stays on and doesn't smudge. Tip is soft and the application is so smooth.

I bought this not expecting major results. To my surprise, I have seen a large amount of growth in length and strength of my lashes. They fan out so pretty and I dont need to apply major coats of mascara to get full lashes anymore. Love Love Love!

I have very sensitive eyes, plus I wear daily contacts, so finding a good, percise tip, liquid liner was impossible... Till Physicians Formula! No flaking and stays put with no irritation! Plus it actually does boost the number and thickness of your lashes with repeated usage! Love it!

Very expensive, but the most amazing liquid eyeliner. The tip is super precise and easy to use. The color lasts all day and doesn't smudge.

I got this eyeliner in Deep Brown. I love the color of it, it is much less harsh than my typical black liners and it really highlights my eyes. I love the eyeliner. It has an almost brush-like applicator that makes it super easy to apply and it applies really smoothly. It looks like liquid eyeliner when its on, but it is about as easy to apply as pencil ones. I got it because it was almost free after coupons and deals at CVS, even though I didn't really need the "eyelash boosting" part. I can definitely tell that my eyelashes have gotten even longer though (I wish I took before and after pictures). I definitely recommend it if you want longer eyelashes, and I recommend it even if you don't really need longer lashes like I did, just because it really is a great eyeliner.