Will buy forever

Wear this eye pencil every day on my water line! Can make it faint or extremely black! Glides on like butter! Sometime hard to get a new one started but use on back of hand and after that no problems!

Love it

I switched to this because I was looking for a more natural product, and I love it! It is easy to use and the colour is really good. I will definitely purchase this again!

I picked this up at the drugstore recently because I was out of my usual eyeliner and noticed a three pack of these on sale. Given the price, I thought it was worth a try and I have to say I am pretty impressed. There is a subtle glitter in the eyeliner which really makes your eyes pop. It wears really well too - stays in place all day long (I even feel asleep with my makeup on and was surprised it still looked remarkably good the next morning. I would buy this eyeliner again. The package I picked up contained 3 "metallic" eye pencils in various shades of brown and grey which I think was called "neutral" - they are all really flattering colours. At $9.99 the package was a bargain.

It's the best eyeliner I've ever purchased. Inexpensive, available at drug stores and it works like magic. I'm very clumsy when it comes to eye make up but this glides on so well. And it lasts all day even without primer!

I purchased this eyeliner the other day during a sale. My eyes have been super itchy lately and I figured trying something organic may help with that.
The packaging in great - the cover stays on well and I don't have to worry about it coming open in my makeup bag, and the pencil sharpener is a nice bonus.
Unfortunately this liner is not dark enough for me. I end up applying several coats which causes my eyes to become irritated and water. Though it says it is waterproof, by the time I am done applying my makeup it is practically all gone.
I wanted to like this product, and I'll continue to use it until it is gone, but I will not repurchase.

I am reviewing this product because I just realized I am almost out of it and it has been my best friend for the past few months. This pencil is great for those of us who are not the best at applying eyeliner. The texture is smooth which makes it extra easy to apply. It gives a liquid look without the hassle. If you have a shaky hand but love dramatic eyeliner, this product is for you!

I was looking at the other reviews and wow! maybe i got a bad one! First of all when i bought it i got the wrong color :O then it would NOT show up at all!! and then the actual eyeliner broke and fell out! D:< HATE THT! so i just had alot of problems with this which i was odd cause i like Physician's Formula!!

This is the first eyeliner I ever used! great starter eyeliner!!

I can't live without this eyeliner! You don't have to worry about sharpening the pencil, as you just have to rotate the bottom and more of the pencil comes out. It goes on very easily and smoothly. It is by far my favorite eyeliner I've ever tried, and I can't go a day without wearing it!!!

This eye liner is one of my everyday make-up essentials, I absolutely LOVE it!
This liner is special and different than others for a few reasons:
1. This eye liner is one of the "automatic" sharpeners. It basically means that you probably won't ever have to sharpen the liner once you open it. You only have to twist it to get more liner. I know there are other eye liners available like this but none of the others that I have tried have ALSO included this: There is a cap on the bottom of the liner you can pull of that has a little sharpener so you can sharpen your liner if you feel the need to! I love this idea, it's absolutely great and I wish more products had it.
2. It goes on extremely smoothly! One stroke on each eye will give you a perfect and defined look.
3. It's not messy! It will give you that perfect look without having to use liquid eye liner which can be extremely messy.

The only thing that could be better about this is the price but I feel that due to the effectiveness of this product, it is well worth a few extra dollars! I DEFINITELY recommend this product to everyone!