If you want an eyeliner that stays for a second

If I could give it no stars i would. The shade isn't on the options but its called Opal Overcoat. I got this from a subscription box. The colour isn't what I would necessarily prefer but since it was on my box and I'm always open to trying new products, so I figured why not? Gave it a swatch on the back of my hand and was impressed by how easy it was to put on. Now learning that it's supposed to be "waterproof" just really confuses me because when I lightly swiped my finger on the swatch, it literally came off, with no effort. and it's supposed to be water proof? Pixi isn't the cheapest brand out there by any means but this is just a disappointing miss. There's so much more brands that are WAYYYYYY cheaper for better quality. Not going to tell anybody not to buy this product because I believe that you need to try everything to know what works for YOU but, this, i don't know how I could possibly make this work.