I bought this eyeliner on sale and in a plum colour ("Rio de Janiero") because it has a pencil tip on one end and liquid liner tip on the other. I typically prefer liquid liner because it tends to have much richer, saturated colour which I was looking forward to in this product. Very disappointed that the liquid liner is nearly sheer and basically undetectable at all on the lash line, and the pencil could be any liner, any colour. Nothing special, pass on this one if you're looking for something a bit different.