I love this eye pencil, it is one of the ONLY drugstore pencils I've tried that STAYS ON FOR 16 HOURS. All the other eye pencils always smudge on me but this one lasts soooo long, I love it! I always purchase this in black and it is super pigmented so it shows up really nice whenever I tightline the inside of my eye!

I have use this product since I started doing my make up. I have tried multiple other brands but I have always found myself coming back to this one. Love Love LOVE this product.

I loved the way the eyeliner went on and stayed in place

I am picky when it comes to eye liner. I was searching for a reasonably priced liner that would stay on all day and go on smoothly. Well, this is it! I put it on at 6 am and could go all day without re-touching it. I like a more dramatic look so I end up just touching it up in the afternoon and I'm good until bedtime! This liner goes on so smooth you can even achieve the look of a liquid liner with ease! I use the 201 Black colour. Great quality for a great price!

i like very much this product cause it is really stay an it make beautiful eye an the price is low

I like this one, It applies nicely, and does last quite a few hours. Ive had trouble in the past with some that have made my eyes water, too sensitive etc, but this one I can wear without any troubles.

This is dry,it tugs and gives the worst black payoff. It works for a lot of people,not me. I tried to warm it with a lighter to melt it to a smoother consistency. Still no luck. Raccoon eyes.

I love their liquid eyeliner its effective.
My only problem with it , is it doesnt stay long on your face , I didnt feel like it was colorstay.
I also would have liked more if it was waterproof .
Its fine , there are better products if you are looking for liquid eyeliners.

This eyeliner is pretty awesome for a drugstore item! I have the black color, and it is truly pigmented and glides on quite well. I like that it's an automatic pencil, and the tip is the perfect size- not too thin and not too thick- for either wiggling between lashes or creating a thicker line. Besides the creamy formula and great pigmentation, it's staying power is only so-so. I wore this for a 50 minute pilates session, and at the end, my wing was a little bit patchy and not as dark black as when I'd applied it. However, if you are only wearing this on the upper lashline and don't intend to sweat like crazy, it should last just fine. I wouldn't recommend it for waterline use, though, since it didn't really hold up to mere sweat on my upper line. So if you're only into lining the lashline and not the waterline, and you want a decently priced, pigmented, and smooth/creamy liner, this is great for you! (Sidenote: wait for a sale and/or coupon for this. $8 isn't too shabby for a liner, but it'll come down much cheaper and worth your money if you get a discount)

This is my most favourite eyeliner pencil of all time. The twist makes it super easy to use, and you never have to find a sharpner.
It glides on and is easy to adjust the depth. I don't use black eyeliner all that much, but I love it specifically for tightlining when I want a defined but natural look.