I have been using this product for years and years. My sisters and are in love with this. It doesn't smudge, stays in place all day and does not cause irritation.

applicator tip actually allows for a very thin line to be applied - a plus when you want to not have too dramatic of a look for day to day wear. My favorite is the brown as its got a gold fleck to it that makes my eyes just pop

That's my favorite one ! I always come back to this one because !

I was always resistante in purchasing a liquid eyeliner, but since I tried this, I can finally get the look I want!