I've wholeheartedly embraced the chubby trend over the past year and I have to say this is one of the best ones I've tried. It's not advertised as a stain but I find that it does leave behind a nice tint and the balm is decently moisturizing. I also like that the scent is a vanilla/cake smell and not some sickly sweet smell or the mint smell that a lot of these have.

In general I like these so-called "Lippies" and I find that the lower end ones are just as good as the midlevel ones. I haven't tried something like a Clinique yet, so we're in Revlon, Rimmel, NYColours territory here. These were on sale today so for $5 I thought I'd try one. The colour is bright, there's a lipstaining effect that stayed through a snack and no minty effect that makes your lips tingle.