I am very torn with this product ...
I really loved the colour of the liner that I had purchased (East End Snob) it was a medium toned, neutral pink. I can't seem to find another liner out there that is similar to this shade. They are all either too light or too dark and so for this reason, I MAY repurchase this ..
The texture is very soft and gel-like .. actually, it is too soft. The pencil would break nearly every time I would apply it to my lips. EVERY TIME. I couldn't apply any pressure to this product without it snapping .. the liner only costed me around $5.99 and so, I am aware that it is cheap but I was hoping to get more than a week out of it. It was breaking so much that I barely even go to use it - the majority of the product broke off and ended in the garbage. Also, because it was so soft the tip of the liner would get almost "smooshed" and so it wasn't very useful for precise lining and only really worked for filling the lips in .. I had a hard time tracing the lines of my my lips in a clean, sharp way.
A positive though, the liner did not feel dry on my lips at all. In fact, it was very moisturizing and to my surprise, lasted the majority of the day .. I just cannot bring myself to spend another $5.99 on a product that isn't going to last and will break.

Decent product - good colours, easy to use. Doesn't last long.