I want to like it, but don't

I tried this product because it had good reviews on EWG's Skin Deep saying it had ingredients that were not as toxic as many other eyeliners. I wanted to like this product, but I found it wasn't as good as other products. I found the colour fades throughout the day, and can easily smear if you have oily skin. Also, when washing it off, instead of flaking off, it disintegrates making it easy to get into your eyes. In conclusion, it's a good eyeliner in terms of toxicity, but it doesn't work as well as other eyeliners.

Rimmel Exaggerate Liquid Eye Liner is my go to eye liner! It's pointed tip offers easy, even application and creates a nice thin line across the eye. It goes on smooth and dries quickly so I never have to worry about it getting all over my eyelids. It also distributed evenly, and is long lasting, usually lasting throughout the whole day. As it is basically shaped like a felt tip marker you have the ability to create a custom eye liner look to change things up!
I definitely recommend this to anyone looking for an easy to use, long lasting liquid liner.