Works great

This is my day to day eyeliner. It take a little getting used to for anyone not used to liquid eyeliner but it works well. Price is good and it lasts the whole day. It isn't waterproof but that is the only down fall

Favourite eyeliner!

This product is very pigmented and easy to use. It is my go to eyeliner. I love the pointed tip, it makes it very easy to get clean lines. The product doesn’t smudge either!

Disappointing

I honestly do not know whether I was doing something wrong or I had received a defective item. My main issue was no matter what I did or how I did it, the beginning of each application was a blob (too much eyeliner). There isn’t much control over whether you want thick or thin lines. The thin lines tended to trail off throughout.

I found the applicator easy to use and it is most definitely waterproof. For these reasons I erred on the side of caution and gave 3 stars.

As I said I can’t be sure if it was human error or I received a faulty product.

Perfect liner

This is my go to liquid liner. I havent found one better than this yet. It creates the perfect line without smudging and is really easy to apply. It can dry out and get crusty though so the tube doesnt last long.

fab

great eyeliner easy to apply love the stick lasts for ages too and the colour is black doesnt go grey and watery like some that iv tried. quite good value especially when on a 3 for 2 sale

Very black and long lasting eyeliner!

I love this eyeliner! Lasts all day, super black, and I have no trouble applying it. Considering the price, I think this is a steal. Rimmel never seems to disappoint.

Fine if your willing to spend time applying multiple layers

Was happy when I first put it on but shortly after ran into my main issue..,
It disappears? Only some of what I applied was actually still there. Had to apply 4 times to get an almost even appearance.

Great eyeliner.

I was never a fan of liquid eyeliner until I tried this one.
It goes on so smoothly and has such a great dark tint.
This is my go to when I need a new eyeliner.

Best drugstore eyeliner

I think I have purchased at least 7 of these. The tip is super precise! It's also super black and it lasts all night long without smudging. Truly recommend.

I want to like it, but don't

I tried this product because it had good reviews on EWG's Skin Deep saying it had ingredients that were not as toxic as many other eyeliners. I wanted to like this product, but I found it wasn't as good as other products. I found the colour fades throughout the day, and can easily smear if you have oily skin. Also, when washing it off, instead of flaking off, it disintegrates making it easy to get into your eyes. In conclusion, it's a good eyeliner in terms of toxicity, but it doesn't work as well as other eyeliners.