I bought this one because I run out of my eyeliner and needed one quickly. The tip is made out of felt so it's very precise opposite to the brush ones. But the color was not black more like a grey color, I even checked the package to see if I grab a grey instead of a black but no, it was the "black" color. It also claims to be water proof wich it isn't, it disappeared after an hour of wearing it! Such a waste of money!

Was excited to try this eyeliner in the Nude shade, but it is too much like a concealer colour, doesn't brighten my eyes, makes them look weird!