Not the worst

The first few times I used it I didn't mind it, however all luster it had going for it faded quick. The "shake it" feature doesn't really seem to serve any purpose.

Okay Product

In theory this is a really good idea for a mascara - I find mine are always drying out so it's a cool idea to be able to shake it and freshen it up. While it does still disperse new product when you shake it after a while (i tried it and then waited about a month) the formula is so wet that it is hard to work with. It made my lashes very crispy which is not something I enjoy. It didn't exactly give them volume or length, it mainly just coated them.
If you are someone who doesn't wear mascara very often, then it's probably going to be a good product for you. But if you wear it every day then there's definitely better mascaras out there.

black eyelids

At first i was really excited when i received this product for FREE in the mail. However, it's one of the worst mascaras ive tried. It's a really wet formula and it goes all over your eye area and it never seems to dry....don't recommend:(