Loved it!

I really liked it this eyeshadow creme because it really blended smoothly and it was nice to have something with a different type of texture. I loved the pigment and it was great because it didn’t rub off

Gotta have this

This is the bomb. It's no the one that cakes but is rather light so you don't feel like your eyelids are weighing you down. The consistency is just right.

I bought this on a whim and so glad I did. It is an amazing eye shadow. Lasts and lasts. Really quality for an affordable price. Seems higher end even though it is cheap.

I purchase a brown colour and wasn't that pleased with the product. by the end of the day the product had creased and left it looking like I had applied it two days ago

I wasn't thrilled with this cream shadow, I found it didn't stay on very well, after an hour or so it was worn off

I didn't realize this was a cream make up when I purchased it, but that was my own fault. The colours don't blend very well. It's messy and difficult to apply well. I found that it looked caked on and I've never used it since trying it after purchasing it. Not worth the purchase, unfortunatly.

this eyeshadow is a pain to apply, the colors dont blend nicely and its creased within minutes... looks cool and pretty in the pot but on the face nooo way!!!

I don't know how you girls got this to stay on all day! It creased up horrible on my eyes an hour after I applied it! Ahh! I loved the color and the glitter but creasing is way gross.

the colors blend so well. and they stay on all day. the only bad thing i found was that it broke up way too easily.

Ulta.com tells us that Stir It Up Eyeshadow is a cream eyeshadow that is comprised of three colors that you "stir" up to make a deep-looking shade. Frankly, when I stirred it up, all I got was a big mess with some huge flecks of glitter. Like the glitter that my kids use at preschool. In pink. It's rather disappointing, really, because the three colors in the pan really look like something I would use. And since I bought something out of the Underground line, I was counting on a bit more glitz than I was used to. But not big huge flakes of glitter. That's just not the look I want during the day. Or ever, really. But the consistency was nice, and it did go on smoothly and evenly, and lasted all day. So perhaps I was overzealous with my stirring. Or I should have used a brush rather than my finger. I'm not ready to write this one off yet, since other Rimmel products I've tried I've been quite happy with. But I wouldn't go get another one of these hoping for a better result just yet.