The brush is perfect very big and fluffy but the product itself is very smudgy and clumpy. I used it twice and the third time it started clumping. It doesn't really give you "extra super" lashes but it gives a good result.

I'm always on a hunt for the perfect mascara. I love Rimmel London and own a few of their mascara's so I decided to try this one.
Rimmel London claims this product "builds lashes from natural to dramatic by thickening and lengthening lashes coat after coat". Which it does!
It doesn't rub off or flake which is a bonus. This mascara is great for people who wear false lashes, since it seperates and darkens your lashes.
Overall a great mascara!

To get this mascara for free, all I had to do was trade in my old mascara. Now I had just bought a new mascara from another company and was a little apprehensive of trading my brand new expensive mascara to get a brand that I didn't really know. WOWWWWWWWWWWWWW is all I can say about it. This mascara beats all the other on the market for non clumping, long lasting, lengthening and thickening your lashes. It's also waterproof to boot. I will never buy another brand of mascara ever again. Rimmel London is the only brand of mascara I can trust.

I totally agree with Sbonin, I had a horrible time with this mascara and just ended up throwing it away. It was very annoying how clumpy my eyelashes got and I hated the curved wand, it was completely useless!

This is definitely a case of you get what you paid for. The price is good but the product is horrible. The curved wand held more product than necessary. Several eyelashes clumped into one GIANT lash. The application was difficult usually leading to getting some on my skin. It also flaked quite easily after only a few hours. Not a makeup staple.

This is a wonderful, non-clumpy mascara for very natural, defined looking lashes. I like that the formula is moist, but no so wet as to make your lashes clump together and get the dreaded spider legs look. I don't need to use a lash comb to separate my lashes out once I have put this mascara on. It gives a nice lift and lengthening effect to my lashes, yet still looks completely natural. This is my go to everyday mascara.

This is my everyday go to mascara. Put one or two coats for day or a couple more for night and your lashes look much more dramatic!. It lengthens, seperates, and most of all doesn't flake or flatten my lashes by the end of the day. LOVE IT!

Cheap and effective! I have long lashes already, so lengthening really isn't my main concern...but this mascara goes on smoothly and stays on until the end of the day. I don't use makeup remover to take it off; instead, all I have to do is brush my wet fingertips on my lashes a few times then wash my face as normal with cleanser.

Definitely worth the money!

This mascara was truly awful. I never have high expectations with lines as cheap as Rimmel but occasionally they surprise you. The only reason I bought it was because there was a special at Pharma Plus and it was only 1.99. How could I not try it for that price?? I mean at the very least I could write a review. And after using it 3 times, I decided that was all I was going to get from it.

This mascara is just terrible. It didn’t look like I had anything on my lashes, except for the fact that my lashes were clumped together for no apparent reason. Not to mention it stung my eyes (maybe I have sensitive eyes?). It did very little of anything so I just chucked it out. Don’t waste your money.

Also, (I know this is a superficial observation) but the name Extra Super Lash is just silly to begin with … especially if your product doesn’t actually deliver on those claims.