I have to say that I am quite pleased with it

I recently purchased the Covergirl Plumply Mascara on Amazon and was very excited to try it. I typically buy Maybeline mascara but am not overly attached to it so I feel that I was still able to give a very objective review. After using the product for the last few weeks, I have to say that I am quite pleased with it. The mascara itself has great color and definition, making my lashes really stand out. It is also very easy to remove and doesn't result in a loss of too many lashes.

The only con: the brush! I thought it was way too chunky and just makes such a mess. It requires so much precision and effort to get it right and will often require a little bit of a cleanup. If they'd tweak the brush a bit then I'd definitely buy the mascara again and recommend it to my peers.