This is by far the worst eyeliner that I have ever used! It came very highly recommended by the staff at Sephora because it is a new product bundle (the bundle is the eyeliner, as well as a Sephora eyeliner brush). The product is just terrible. I would consider myself a liquid eyeliner pro, as it something that I have used every day for the last 15 years, but I could not make this product work at all. It was like it was dried out moments after opening it!

I returned it!