I discovered the Sephora Waterproof Eye Liner Pencil this winter and I love it! It has great staying power - especially if you add a little bit of black powder over top. Comes in lots of fun colours and is priced at only $12.00 Canadian on the Sephora.ca site. Also it is dense enough to last for quite some time - even with sharpening every couple of days. A great inexpensive liner that stays put!